Lyle and Erik Menendez have spent more than three decades behind bars for the killing of their parents. But this story is far more complicated than the media circus made it out to be in the 1990s.
What if I told you these men never got a fair trial?
What if I told you we now have evidence, expert knowledge, and testimony that could change everything?
In 1996, the Menendez brothers were sentenced to life in prison without parole for the murder of their parents, José and Kitty Menendez. The prosecution painted them as spoiled rich kids, angry about being cut off financially. The media fed the frenzy. The audience ate it up.
But buried beneath the headlines was this: they were victims.
The brothers alleged years of sexual, physical, and emotional abuse at the hands of their father. They said they feared for their lives. Their first trial ended in a hung jury. But by the time the second trial began, cameras were banned, key witnesses were barred from testifying, and the emotional abuse narrative was all but erased from the courtroom.
In the early ’90s, we didn’t talk about male survivors of sexual abuse. We didn’t understand trauma responses. We didn’t have trauma-informed courtrooms. And frankly, we didn’t care.
But now we do. And that changes everything.
We should. And legally, we can.
Here are the real paths forward:
Recent documentaries have revealed previously unheard testimony, including a cousin of the brothers who says she witnessed signs of sexual abuse and was silenced. That qualifies as new evidence.
Our courts now recognize that long-term abuse can lead to what’s called “battered person syndrome” a psychological condition that impacts a victim’s perception of threat. If this defense had been fully developed at trial, the outcome might have been different.
The Governor of California has the power to commute their sentences or pardon them. That requires public will and legal support, but it’s possible and overdue.
If ineffective legal counsel, jury misconduct, or procedural errors occurred. Evidence suggests the brothers may qualify for habeas relief or a motion for a new trial.
Let’s talk about fairness.
Gypsy Rose Blanchard helped murder her mother after a lifetime of abuse and control. She served eight years and is now free. She’s doing interviews, building a following, and reclaiming her life.
The Menendez brothers? Still locked away. No parole. No second chances.
How can we justify that?
As a civil rights attorney, I’ve represented survivors of trauma in schools, prisons, and churches. I’ve watched the legal system fail the most vulnerable, over and over again. But the Menendez case is one of the most blatant miscarriages of justice I’ve seen.
This isn’t about absolving them of guilt.
It’s about applying justice equally.
It’s about understanding that trauma, fear, and abuse matter—in every courtroom, not just the ones that make it to Netflix.
Justice doesn’t expire. And neither should our willingness to correct it.
—Don Smolen
Civil Rights Attorney | Advocate for the Forgotten
Smolen Law's mission is to provide exceptional legal services with integrity, professionalism, and respect.
Choose the Oklahoma law firm that gets results: Smolen Law.
