At the center of McCleary v. Nexstar is a simple but serious mistake. One that shows how quickly lives can be affected when basic verification doesn’t happen.
This case is not about fake news or made-up crimes. It is about what happens when the wrong person is shown as a criminal on television.
There was a real federal sex-trafficking case in Texas. It involved several defendants and was legitimately newsworthy.
An Oklahoma television station decided to report on that case for its viewers.
The original Texas news report did not include a photograph of one of the defendants, a man named Christopher McCleary.
To make the story more visually engaging, a local producer decided to add a photo. She searched the Oklahoma Department of Corrections website and found a mugshot of a man with the same name.
That man was not the defendant.
The producer later admitted she was trained to verify the identities of criminal defendants by:
She also admitted she did not do any of that in this case.
Instead, she relied solely on the mugshot she found online.
The photo aired belonged to Christopher Renyles McCleary, an Oklahoma resident with no connection to the Texas case.
Viewers saw his face while hearing about sex-trafficking charges, a crime he was never accused of and had nothing to do with.
After the broadcast, Mr. McCleary filed a lawsuit against the TV station and its parent company.
He alleged:
The station did not dispute that the photo was incorrect.
The media companies asked the court to dismiss the lawsuit using Oklahoma’s anti-SLAPP law, which is meant to protect free speech and news reporting.
Their argument was that the plaintiff had not met the high legal standard required to continue the case.
The Oklahoma Court of Civil Appeals ruled that:
The court did not decide who ultimately wins. It only decided that the case deserves to be heard.
This case is not about punishing journalism. It is about basic accuracy and accountability.
The court made clear that:
A real crime was reported.
The wrong person’s photo was used.
No identity verification happened.
An innocent person was publicly linked to a serious crime.
The court ruled that he deserves his day in court.
And that distinction matters, for journalists, for the public, and for anyone who expects their name and face to be treated with care.
Smolen Law's mission is to provide exceptional legal services with integrity, professionalism, and respect.
Choose the Oklahoma law firm that gets results: Smolen Law.
