Justice for Cindy: Civil Rights Attorney Speaks Out After Gateway Founder Seeks Payout Post-Abuse Claims

Tulsa, OK — In the wake of sexual abuse allegations against Robert Morris, founding pastor of Gateway Church, attorney Don Smolen is publicly calling out the church’s failures—and what he calls the “unbelievable audacity” of Morris’s request for a substantial retirement payout.

Morris, who resigned in June 2024 following allegations from Cindy Clemishire, is reportedly seeking a bulk retirement sum despite admitting to “inappropriate sexual behavior” with a minor during his early ministry.

“This isn’t just wrong, it’s disgraceful,” said Smolen. “Cindy has lived with trauma, PTSD, and spiritual pain for decades. And now her abuser wants to cash out?”

🔍 Timeline of the Scandal:

  • 1982–1987: Cindy Clemishire alleges repeated sexual abuse by Morris, starting when she was just 12.
  • 2005: Cindy contacts Morris directly. A former elder confirms her account and yet the church remains silent.
  • 2024: Cindy goes public. Morris resigns and simultaneously requests a financial payout for his “retirement.”

Smolen says this situation is textbook: protect the leader, discredit the victim, and quietly pay out power.

“This isn’t accountability. This is corruption dressed in faith.”

Why Don Smolen Is Speaking Out:

Smolen has represented survivors of church, school, and institutional abuse for years and says this case demands national attention because it shows how broken the system is.

  • A survivor silenced for decades.
  • An abuser allowed to lead unchecked.
  • A resignation followed by a money grab.
  • And a church that still hasn’t made it right.

What Needs to Change:

1. No retirement packages for admitted abusers.
    If you harm a child, you don’t get a check—you get held accountable.

2. NDAs and church-controlled “investigations” must end.
    Survivors deserve transparency, not control.

3. Churches must offer reparations and trauma-informed care.
    Not “prayer and silence”—actual, independent therapy and support.

Message to Survivors:

“If I were your lawyer, I’d tell you this: They don’t get to walk away rich while you live in pain. We see you. We believe you. And we will stand beside you until justice is served.”

If you or someone you know has been impacted by church abuse or cover-ups, contact Smolen Law at www.smolen.law/contact or email don@smolen.law.
All inquiries are confidential. Survivors will be treated with dignity and belief.

Smolen Law's mission is to provide exceptional legal services with integrity, professionalism, and respect.

Choose the Oklahoma law firm that gets results: Smolen Law.

The numbers don't lie...

$40,000,000 Insurance Bad Faith
$16,733,096 Semi-Truck Accident
$10,250,000 Civil Rights
$8,757,500 Civil Rights
$8,414,190 Insurance Bad Faith
$8,055,991 Medical Malpractice
$6,011,855 Car Wreck
$6,000,000 Civil Rights
$6,000,000 Catastrophic Injury
$5,800,000 Workplace Accident
$5,730,048 Tractor Rollover
$5,581,092 Semi-Truck Accident
$5,000,915 Semi-Truck Accident / Wrongful Death
$3,800,000 Insurance Bad Faith
$3,300,600 Products Liability
$3,100,000 Car Wreck
$3,000,000 Semi-Truck Accident
$3,000,000 Defective Product
$2,800,000 Products Liability
$2,000,000 Medical Malpractice
$2,000,000 Medical Malpractice
$1,900,000 Birth Trauma
$1,774,000 Insurance Bad Faith
$1,739,632 Personal Injury
$1,500,000 Medical Malpractice
$1,375,000 Medical Malpractice
$1,225,000 Insurance Bad Faith
$1,205,000 Assault / Abuse of Process
$1,125,000 Birth Trauma
$1,100,000 Civil Rights
$1,029,233 Personal Injury
$1,008,000 Defective Product
$875,000 Insurance Bad Faith
$810,000 Defective Product
$775,000 Birth Trauma
$750,000 Medical Malpractice
$746,250 Nursing Home Neglect
$710,000 Semi-Truck Accident
$700,000 Civil Rights
$675,000 Premises Liability
$600,000 Semi-Truck Accident
$549,000 Medical Neglect
$525,000 Insurance Bad Faith
$500,000 Medical Malpractice
$500,000 Insurance Bad Faith
$481,352 Semi-Truck Accident
$465,437 Insurance Bad Faith
$400,000 Medical Malpractice
$375,000 Medical Malpractice
$350,000 Medical Neglect
$350,000 Insurance Bad Faith
$350,000 Medical Malpractice
$350,000 Insurance Bad Faith
$337,500 Semi-Truck Accident
$325,000 Nursing Home Neglect
$325,000 Insurance Bad Faith
$325,000 Insurance Bad Faith
$324,830 Insurance Bad Faith
$312,139 Semi-Truck Accident
$280,000 Nursing Home Neglect
$275,000 Products Liability
$265,098 Semi-Truck Accident
$250,000 Church Abuse
$250,000 Personal Injury
$250,000 Semi-Truck Accident
$247,790 Insurance Bad Faith
$245,306 Insurance Bad Faith
$242,500 Civil Rights
$241,854 Trust Dispute
$237,500 Insurance Bad Faith
$235,399 Personal Injury
$225,600 Products Liability