Channen Smith has spent more than a decade in an Oklahoma prison insisting he did not pull the trigger in a 2010 shooting that killed one man and wounded a woman outside a north Tulsa home. Now, after years of legal setbacks, a federal judge has agreed to give his innocence claim something it has never had before: four days in court to make its case.
A Tulsa County jury convicted Smith in 2013 of shooting Carlameisha Jefferson and Dominique Jasper outside a home in north Tulsa, according to Oklahoma Watch. The shooting happened outside a home in north Tulsa in the early morning hours of October 23, 2010. Jefferson survived her injuries, but Jasper died in the hospital 23 days later. Prosecutors said at trial that a previous argument and a romantic feud had motivated Smith to drive to the house and open fire.
Smith was sentenced to life in prison for first-degree murder, along with 20 years for shooting with intent to kill, 10 years for discharging a firearm into a dwelling, and 10 years for being a felon in possession of a firearm, the outlet’s report, published through KGOU, notes. Smith has long claimed he was wrongfully convicted, and he now contends that the actual shooter was a man named Arlan Young.
According to the same report, Smith says Young confessed to the crime in detail to two of his cousins before dying of cancer in January 2017. Those cousins, Tomique Thomas and Tiffani Carroll, each said in affidavits that Young admitted he shot Jasper and Jefferson because the two had assaulted him earlier that evening. Both Thomas and Carroll are listed on Smith’s final witness list for the upcoming hearing.
Smith’s broader innocence claim rests on three pillars: Young’s alleged confession, allegations of prosecutorial misconduct, and a claim of ineffective assistance of counsel at trial. Attorney Jennifer West, who helped Smith file his habeas corpus petition, told the outlet she hopes U.S. District Judge Sara Hill will order Smith’s release once the evidentiary hearing concludes. The petition marks the first pro se habeas corpus filing in the case to advance this far, and the law firm Smolen and Associates agreed to take on Smith’s case in July 2025.
In April 2025, Hill found that Smith had presented a credible gateway actual-innocence claim and directed the state to respond, the report states. That finding opened the door to further proceedings but was narrower than it might sound. The following year, on March 30, 2026, Hill clarified that the court had not found Smith actually innocent — only that he had presented a credible gateway claim, stating plainly that the court found only that Smith presented a credible gateway actual innocence claim.
Hill also said the state’s own findings warrant further review but do not undermine her earlier ruling. A four-day evidentiary hearing before Hill had been scheduled to begin Nov. 9, but was postponed to March 2027 because of a death in an attorney’s family.
The Oklahoma Attorney General’s Office, representing the state, maintains the evidence against Smith is strong and argues the court should deny relief, per Oklahoma Watch’s reporting. After investigating following Hill’s April 2025 order, state officials concluded that Young’s confession was implausible. The state plans to present evidence it says shows Smith and his advocates fabricated a story implicating Young.
Among the state’s evidence: officials allege medical records show Young was too ill to leave his house to go grocery shopping with Thomas around the time she says he confessed, just a week before his death. The state also points to testimony expected from Brandon Savage, who identified Smith as the shooter and has testified that Smith confessed to him while the two were detained together at the Tulsa County jail. Savage plans to testify that he was later offered money to change his story. Jasper’s mother has also testified that her son identified Smith as the shooter before he died.
Carrie Burkhart, deputy press secretary for the Attorney General’s Office, declined to offer further comment to Oklahoma Watch, saying the state’s filings speak for themselves. The outlet reported it was unable to reach Smolen Law for comment. West, for her part, has called the state’s collusion theory far-fetched, telling the outlet there is little physical evidence in the case and no compelling reason for Young’s cousins to invent their account.
A favorable habeas decision would not necessarily guarantee Smith’s freedom. Judges granting habeas petitions may instead remand a case back to district court for retrial or resentencing, per the U.S. Department of Justice process described in the reporting. Smith’s petition originally asserted four claims challenging the lawfulness of his custody under the Tulsa County District Court judgment, and a federal district court opinion hosted by Justia shows the court granted in part and denied in part the state’s motion to dismiss that petition in 2025, after the state had primarily argued Smith filed his claims too late under the one-year federal habeas statute of limitations.
Read the article on Hoodline.
Smolen Law's mission is to provide exceptional legal services with integrity, professionalism, and respect.
Choose the Oklahoma law firm that gets results: Smolen Law.